Inspiring ILM

What drives people to work in the visual effects industry? The glamour? The technology? All those ravening monsters and exploding spaceships? Or is it just another job? In an ongoing series of articles, we ask a wide range of VFX professionals the simple question: “Who or what inspired you to get into visual effects?”

Here are the responses from the staff at Industrial Light & Magic.

Prehistoric Encounters

When asked what inspired him to get into visual effects, Michael DiComo, CG technology supervisor (ILM, San Francisco), was in no doubt, answering, “Simple: Jurassic Park. Seeing the effects in that movie made me realise that THAT was what I wanted to do for a living. The great thing is that, not only did I get hired by ILM only three years after Jurassic Park was released, but I also got to work on The Lost World: Jurassic Park as my second film project ever.”

Beverley Joy Ang, production engineer (ILM, Singapore), was also inspired by dinosaurs, but of a more cuddly kind.

“I remember stumbling upon this program called CorelMove during grade school,” Ang recalled. “I didn’t know how to do animations back then, but the CorelMove library had this pre-animated purple dinosaur that you could import into a scene. I had a lot of fun changing the backgrounds, adding shrubs and trees, and moving the dinosaur around. I think it’s that little purple dinosaur that kick-started my love for computer graphics.”

The prehistory of cinema has also had its influence today’s VFX professionals.

The Wonderful World of Disney

“Colouring characters in all day – who wouldn’t love that job?” Betsy Mueller, ILM

“Growing up, my family and I used to watch The Wonderful World of Disney movies on Sunday evenings,” commented Betsy Mueller, lighting technical director (ILM, Vancouver).

“One episode was introduced with an old black-and-white clip in which Walt Disney explained what some of the traditional animation departments did. The Ink and Paint department fascinated me! Colouring characters in all day – who wouldn’t love that job? That was when I became hooked on the magic of making movies.”

Mad About the ’80s

Many people currently working in visual effects have a soft spot for the films of the 1980s, that golden age of fantasy and adventure movies that marks the high point of optical and photochemical effects.

One such person is Danielle O’Hare, senior manager of technical training (ILM, San Francisco), who remarked, “The reason I started working in VFX was because of movies like Indiana Jones, Back to the Future, and E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial.”

Craig Hammack, visual effects supervisor (ILM, San Francisco) shared O’Hare’s love for this era, and also added a favourite from 1962 into the mix: “I loved the escapism and thrill of Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan, and the absolute beauty of Lawrence of Arabia.”


“Gremlins” – actress Phoebe Cates serves her unusual clientele, while Chris Walas’s crew of puppeteers hunker down out of shot.

Kate Lee, layout artist (ILM, Vancouver), recalled a formative ‘80s moment with a little extra bite. “My earliest memory of a VFX movie scene was Gremlins – launching Mrs. Deagle out of the window in her wheelchair. I was too young to understand that the gremlins weren’t real, and so terrified that I couldn’t go anywhere on my own after dark for a while!”

You can’t ask a group of VFX professionals what inspires them without stumbling over at least one person who loves Star Wars.

“For me, it’s an insatiable appetite for watching movies, a love of the filmmaking process from conception to projection,” stated Daniel Cavey, production manager (ILM, San Francisco). “And of course my first movie theatre memory: my Mom taking me to see The Empire Strikes Back!”

Milestone Movies

Jurassic Park isn’t the only game-changing film that’s proved inspirational to the staff at ILM. Recalling a summer afternoon in 1992 in South Africa, Mike Jutan, animation/creature R&D engineer (ILM, San Francisco), said, “I was a 10 year-old, enthusiastically eating a snack and watching Terminator 2: Judgment Day. Somehow, I’d convinced my parents it was okay to watch it: ‘Don’t worry Mom, this version was edited for TV!’ The moment where the T-1000 melts up from the checkerboard floor cemented my life goals in a matter of seconds. I loved computers, I loved movies, and with this – the single-most awesome visual effect of all time – I loved ILM.

“From there, my career and education goals revolved around combining math, movies and computer science. Fifteen years later, an ILM recruiter called and asked if I’d ever ‘considered working at ILM’. Not attempting to hold back any glee, I laughed, ‘Yes – only since I was 10 years old!’”


“The moment where the T-1000 melts up from the checkerboard floor cemented my life goals in a matter of seconds” – Mike Jutan, ILM

Colette Mullenhoff, R&D engineer (ILM, San Francisco), was also seduced by James Cameron’s metallic assassin from the future: “I always had my sights set on computer graphics for entertainment, but watching the T-1000 liquid metal cyborg in Terminator 2: Judgment Day sealed the deal.”

Another seminal movie for many VFX professionals is The Matrix. “When The Matrix came out, it inspired my high school class to re-create the 360 degree bullet-time scene,” explained Kate Lee, layout artist (ILM, Vancouver). “But we could only improvise with one person holding a camcorder in a car that was spinning around another person, who was leaning back and ever-so-slowly throwing his arms in the air. Clearly there was much to be learned about the technical side of the amazing images!”

Outside the VFX Box

It isn’t always a love of visual effects that draws people into visual effects. Craig Hammack might be a Star Trek fan, but he’s also inspired by architecture. “I have a love for the kind of experience that can be evoked by the light and form of architectural spaces. Architects like Louis Khan, Le Corbusier and Carlos Scarpa capture my imagination through design. While searching for a way to create experiences myself – without the need for understanding civil engineering codes and electrical schematics – I discovered computer graphics, and then visual effects.”

For Johan Thorngren, CG supervisor (ILM, San Francisco), it was all triggered by a passion for military aircraft. “I grew up near a military airbase and loved watching the jets from afar,” he remembered. “I built the kit-models of military airplanes that were available at the time. Due to a random chance in my previous career, I got hold of a copy of 3DSMax and picked up model-building as a hobby again – this time digitally. This led me to explore rigging and the FX aspects related to the models, as well as propelling me into the rendering and shading side of things. So I very quickly started to get more interested in making synthetic things look real.”

An aptitude for computer science can help lead to a career in visual effects, but on its own it may not always be enough – as the experience of Wajid Raza, technical director (ILM, San Francisco) proves. “In the late 90’s, when I was in middle school, my parents got me a Pentium computer,” Wajid recalled. “I was instantly hooked on the graphics packages – including an early version of Adobe Photoshop. A few years later, still fascinated with computers, I enrolled in an undergraduate computer science program.

“But during my second year of college, I started to get bored – it was not as creatively satisfying as I had hoped it to be. That was when Peter Jackson’s The Lord of The Rings came out. I was floored with the whole experience – the CG characters and epic battle scenes. I spent the next two years finding out everything about VFX, and eventually landed my dream job at Industrial Light & Magic.”


“The Lord of the Rings” – “I was floored with the whole experience – the CG characters and epic battle scenes” – Wajid Raza, ILM

However, the ultimate outside-the-box story comes from Jon Alexander, compositing supervisor (ILM, San Francisco), who puts it all down to, well, a higher power.

“I bounced around four universities, studying different sorts of engineering, but my heart was not in it,” commented Alexander. “My parents suggested I enrol at Mary Manse, the small Catholic college where my Mom was on the faculty, because tuition would be free. But I wanted to go to a film school. My Dad said, “Your Mom’s praying that you just get a degree.” I snottily replied, “I’m praying to go to film school.” But I enrolled anyway.

“A month or so later the Ursuline nuns who ran the school said that, after much prayer and because of the financial situation, that it was God’s will that the school was closing after 50 years. My Dad called me up and said, “Okay I guess its God’s will you go to film school, but you’ve really pissed off a bunch of nuns!”

The Final Effect

Whatever inspired these ILM-ers to get into the business in the first place, it’s clear that, years later, their passion remains strong.

“To this day, whenever we get a new Jurassic movie in house, I get all jazzed up by the artwork, dinosaur maquettes, motion and lighting tests,” remarked Michael diComo. “It makes me want to roll up my sleeves and be a shot-lighter again.”

“In 2003, ILM called me up and asked if I wanted to come and work on Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith,” recalled Johan Thorngren. “I was a bit hesitant, until I heard that ILM had a department that allowed people to work in many different areas at once. Now I get to jump into many different aspects of the work, and I find it really satisfying being part of a team responsible for a given shot or sequence of shots.”

Danielle O’Hare concluded, “The reason I’ve stayed at ILM is because of the incredibly talented and generous population of artists, producers, and engineers. These are people at the top of their game, who are more than happy to share what they know with their peers. It makes my job as a training manager very easy, and a whole lot of fun.”

For some, however, working in VFX poses one problem that can be insurmountable. As Kate Lee quipped: “The biggest challenge is to get my parents to understand what I do for living.”

ILM LogoIndustrial Light & Magic was founded by George Lucas in 1975. Since then, ILM has created visual effects for more than 250 feature films, notably the movie franchises Transformers, Iron Man, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Jurassic Park, Pirates of the Caribbean and, of course, Star Wars. ILM has offices in San Francisco, Singapore, Vancouver and London. Thanks to all the staff from ILM who contributed to this article.

Special thanks to Greg Grusby. “Terminator 2: Judgment Day” photograph copyright © 1991 by Carolco Pictures, Inc. “Gremlins” photograph copyright © 1984 by Warner Bros., Inc. “The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring” photograph copyright © 2001 by New Line Cinema.

“Interstellar” Wins VFX Oscar

Cinefex 140 "Interstellar" cover

Christopher Nolan’s space epic Interstellar has won the Academy Award for Best Visual Effects at the 87th Academy Awards, in a glittering ceremony held at the Dolby Theatre, Hollywood & Highland Center on February 22, 2015.

The award was collected by Paul Franklin, Andrew Lockley, Ian Hunter and Scott Fisher in recognition of the ground-breaking visual effects images created by Double Negative, with on-set special effects orchestrated by Scott Fisher, and other practical effects – notably a suite of large-scale spacecraft miniatures – by New Deal Studios.

Complete list of nominees:

  • Interstellar – Paul Franklin, Andrew Lockley, Ian Hunter and Scott Fisher
  • Guardians of the Galaxy – Stephane Ceretti, Nicolas Aithadi, Jonathan Fawkner and Paul Corbould
  • X-Men: Days of Future Past – Richard Stammers, Lou Pecora, Tim Crosbie and Cameron Waldbauer
  • Captain America: The Winter Soldier – Dan DeLeeuw, Russell Earl, Bryan Grill and Dan Sudick
  • Dawn of the Planet of the Apes – Joe Letteri, Dan Lemmon, Daniel Barrett and Erik Winquist

You can read the full story behind Interstellar‘s award-winning visual effects in Cinefex 140. Oh, and while you’re at it, why not catch up on the rest of the nominated films in our previous two issues – links below.

K is for Kinematics

K is for KinematicsIn the VFX ABC, the letter “K” stands for “Kinematics”.

If you’ve ever animated a creature using a piece of 3D software like Autodesk’s Maya or 3DSMax, you’ll know all about kinematics.

If you haven’t, here’s a quick primer …

Imagine you’re going to animate a troll. Just an regular troll: twelve feet tall with massive hands and a bad attitude. Let’s call him Tarquin.

The scene you’re going to animate requires Tarquin to reach out his hand and throttle a nearby dwarf. The dwarf’s name, by the way, is Doug.

Forward Kinematics

One way to perform the task is by using forward kinematics.

This is very tricky. Forward kinematics requires you to animate Tarquin’s arm starting from the shoulder and working your way out. In other words, you move his upper arm a bit, then adjust his forearm, then proceed to his hand, and finally manipulate those fat troll fingers.

The reason this is tricky is because what you really want to do is make sure Tarquin’s fingers connect with Doug’s neck in exactly the right place, at exactly the right time. That’s a tough call when those fingers are always the last appendage on the list of things you move.

Inverse Kinematics

If all that sounds like too much hard work, you might prefer to fall back on inverse kinematics.

This is much more satisfactory. With inverse kinematics, you get to focus entirely on Tarquin’s hand, grabbing it with your cursor moving it from its starting position to, you guessed it, the waiting neck of the poor, doomed Doug.

As for the rest of Tarquin’s arm, you simply rely on the software knowing how all the joints are interconnected, and trust it to move the entire limb accordingly. It’s like moving the hand of a jointed puppet and letting the laws of physics do the rest.

Of course, it’s not quite as simple as that. If you want to get any kind of expression into the movement (and, being an animator, that’s precisely your aim) you have to go in and make adjustments to the gross movement that’s been determined by the software. You know, all those small accelerations and delays, not to mention the unexpected muscle twitches caused by Tarquin’s predilection for strong ale.

If you have friendly rigging team, they might cause certain secondary movements to happen automatically. But it’s still up to you to coax a performance out of your troll.

If you want to learn more about kinematics, you’ll need to dig deep into a software tutorial, like the one in this Maya training video:

However, before you get lost down a rabbit hole filled with IK handles and pole vectors, let’s take a moment to consider the long and illustrious history of the word kinematics. Along the way, we might learn what it actually means.

Kinetographs and Kinetoscopes

One of the earliest devices developed for the presentation of moving pictures was the Kinetoscope. Both it and its counterpart, the Kinetograph, were created in the US at the Edison Lab during the 1890s.

Edison's Kinetoscope was developed during the final decade of the 19th century.

Edison’s Kinetoscope, one of the earliest motion picture viewers, was developed during the final decade of the 19th century.

The Kinetoscope presented moving images to its viewers by causing a strip of perforated celluloid film to pass in front of a light source at high speed, with each successive image on the film being isolated by a moving shutter. If that sounds like a movie projector to you, you’re nearly right.

Although the Kinetoscope contained all the essential components of a typical film projector, it was actually a peephole device, and thus could be viewed by only one person at a time.

As for the Kinetograph, that was the camera used to create the celluloid images in the first place.

By the turn of the century, a number of other inventors had jumped on the motion picture bandwagon, including Louis and August Lumière , whose Cinématographe machine was capable of displaying projected moving images to a large audience.

Kinematics in the Kinema

The root of all these words is the Greek word “kinema”, which means “motion”. As with many Greek words, during its journey across Europe and beyond, the “k” has been transformed into a “c”.

Which is why nobody goes to the kinema any more.

However, you can still find the word “kinema”, in all its derived forms, if you look hard enough. The technical and craft organisation that is the British Kinematograph, Sound and Television Society (BKSTS) – originally formed in 1931 as the British Kinematograph Society – is still going strong.

Then there’s the American Society of Cinematographers (ASC), a non-profit organisation dedicated to the art of filmmaking. Its magazine, American Cinematographer, was first published in 1920. It’s still going strong too.

Finally we have kinematics, that esoteric aspect of the modern art of animation, the mastery of which demands the application of both artistic sensibilities and technical smarts.

And the name of which contains a pleasing echo of the long history of the motion picture craft.

“The Crossing” – VFX Q&A

John Woo's "The Crossing" features environmental visual effects shots by Tippett Studio

The Crossing is a two-part epic disaster movie directed by John Woo (Red Cliff, Mission: Impossible II, Face/Off), set during the Chinese Civil War, and climaxing with the sinking of the luxury liner Taiping in 1949. In the first film, multiple plotlines track the interweaving fortunes of a number of characters through romance and war, setting them up to converge with catastrophe in the closing instalment. Part 1 was released in China in December 2014, with Part 2 due for release in May 2015.

Tippett Studio contributed a number of visual effects shots to The Crossing: Part 1, most of them involving large-scale environments. Key sequences include a re-creation of the bustling city of Shanghai, scenes of the Taiping at sea, and a dramatic battlefield flypast.

In this exclusive VFX Q&A, Tippett Studio’s environment art director, Kent Matheson, reveals the painstaking process of bringing to life the historic events revisited by Woo in the film that’s been described by some as “the Chinese Titanic”.

How did you get involved with The Crossing?

Tippett Studio had worked with John Woo on Red Cliff, so we were on his radar. The connection for The Crossing was made by his post-production supervisor in Beijing, Andy Chen. We had an initial kick-off with John before he was consumed with all the other facets of the film – after this we worked through Andy, who would show our work to John and get his notes back to us.

How many shots did you deliver, and who was on the team?

We delivered ten shots during a two-and-a-half month period. It was a very tight schedule in which we had to research, develop, and execute the shots somewhat simultaneously.

We had a crew of about 20 on the project, divided into separate teams for each environment. The visual effects supervisor was Chris Morley, with Ken Kokka and Yimi Tong producing. On the big Shanghai shot, we had Ross Nakamura as the lead compositor, and Chris Paizis was our head layout guy and scripts wizard. Ben Von Zastrow was our lead technical artist, and Darin Hilton and Pamela Saad contributed immensely.

Let’s talk about the big environment shots. What did they comprise?

There’s a shot that lifts up from the street level of Shanghai’s slum area and travels completely across the city towards the wealthier area of the Bund. It’s kind of a signature image for the film. It describes the contrast between the different levels of the culture – the extreme disparity between the wealthy and the poor areas.

We also created a series of shots of the ship, Taiping, sailing on the open ocean, using plates that were filmed in a studio backlot. In one shot, the camera follows several seagulls as they traverse the length of the ship, passing over the crew and passengers on the various decks before reaching the lead character standing near the prow of the ship. The shot involved water simulations, atmospherics, a full CG ship blended into the plate, and a whole lot of fancy comp work.

In another shot, we explode out from near the barrel of a large cannon to travel over an enormous battlefield full of advancing soldiers and tanks. This began as an aerial plate showing only a few soldiers and a single tank; we filled the land with tanks and CG soldiers, and filled the sky with exploding shells.

Watch Tippett Studio’s video breakdown of the Shanghai establishing shot:

How did you go about researching 1940s Shanghai for the big establishing shot of the city?

Shanghai at the time was an amazing mix of cultures and styles, with aspects of the old world and new mixed together, so we found photos that really captured it well. Hooray for the amazing resource of what people share on the internet!

We collected everything we could – not just the obvious buildings on the Bund, but also old signage, dock photos, posters, people, cars, boats, bicycles, streetlamps, flags and clothing. We wanted to have a very solid idea of each district of the city, so that all the parts we created would properly support the final look and be accurate to the place and time.

Aerial views gave us a sense of the textures and densities of the different regions of the city, while street-level images showed us what we needed to properly detail it. In some cases, we were able to use the reference to directly inform the shot creation. For example, we projected an archival image of the Wusong River on to our CG river plane, and dressed in the boats and supplies in the positions shown on the picture. Chris Morley loved the natural chaos of the photograph, and didn’t want to lose it. You can’t make that stuff up!

How did you begin laying out your CG model of the city?

One of the things we had found in our research was original maps of Shanghai from 1940, so we based our initial layout work on these. We located the key areas needed for our shot, and created a very simple representation of the city, laying in the rivers and bridges in the correct places and using blocks for city buildings and simple models gathered from SketchUp for the landmarks.

We also blocked in the camera move at this stage. We explored various paths, ending up with a move that pulls up and over the secondary river in Shanghai, glides over the commercial district toward the Bund, and finally drops into an upper window of the Peace Hotel.

What was the next stage, once the layout was approved?

We used Esri CityEngine to lay out the streets. We built only what would be seen in the shot, matching to the maps but also fudging a bit where we wanted to create dramatic focuses. This became the base on which we placed the buildings and details.

Shanghai CG model created by Tippett Studio for "The Crossing"

How did you create the various assets needed to bring the layout to life?

We had open categories for assets such as “boats”, “cars”, “trucks” “props” and so on. We divided the buildings into different types – “residential”, “commercial”, “industrial” – and had different styles within those, from older wood structures to more modern ones. These were set up in different configurations and groupings, from single buildings to whole neighbourhood blocks. At first we used a fairly random scattershot approach, but we became more focused as the categories filled up.

In all, we ended up with around 375 separate assets feeding into the shot. All of these were created as fully 3D models, viewable and renderable from all angles. But we were careful to control the level of detail – we built and laid everything out it very much with the mentality of a matte painter. And the requirements of the shot meant that none of the assets needed to be built to what we would usually consider a “hero” level of detail.

What software did you use to build the models?

Many of the models began life in SketchUp, but all were cleaned up, textured and shaded in Maya. Every building and prop was set up with the same mapping inputs, and many shared shader settings – this allowed us to automate and regulate many of the processing tasks.

With so many objects to bring together, we decided to radically simplify the UV and texture process. Therefore, almost all of the objects were baked down to a single UV set. We decided on four basic shader inputs, and then used a single map to drive each of these. This let us speed up not only the creation process, but also the rendering times and memory usage further along the line.

With the models constructed, how did you begin assembling the shot?

We were handed the live-action plates of the head and tail shots – the “bookends” – and given a verbal description of the shot, along with a rough idea of the timing John Woo had in mind.

We broke up the city into different sections and subsections, each of which could be worked on and published separately. Anyone on the team could jump in and work on a specific area as needed, so we were able to “multi-thread” the layout and population effort. We had a few hitches from time to time – cars driving over people or people walking into buildings – but all in all it worked out well.

We added and animated cars and people into the streets as one of the very last stages. The people were realised via very simple models, pre-animated with various walk and talk cycles before being placed into the scene. Additional life was added with flags and other minor animated pieces.

Shanghai CG model created by Tippett Studio for "The Crossing"

Describe the process of rendering out the scene.

All the separate city sections were collected into a master scene file, and the final rendering was done using V-Ray. We made some touch-ups using Glyph’s Mattepainting Toolkit, but most of the scene’s look and detail was handled via the raw CG assets. We also relied heavily on lighting and atmosphere.

The renders were split into various passes and assembled using Nuke. Early on in the process, we had identified several key frames that best represented the major elements of the shot; using these, we’d made well-defined key art representing what Chris Morley wanted to see. That was what we presented to John Woo.

We used the key art throughout the process for reference to lighting and detailing, but it was particularly useful in the comp stage as the rendered layers were assembled. What really helped was having a strong vision of what the shot was going to look like and stickling to it. Chris’s background is in compositing, so he had a strong feeling for how he wanted the elements to come together.

Were any significant changes made to the shot as your work progressed?

We could have adjusted quite easily to camera changes, since we’d built our assets to be used wherever we needed them. But it wasn’t necessary.

However, John Woo liked what was happening in the shot so much that he asked us to extend its duration by about 15 percent. We loved this, because the slower camera let us see more of our work!

Tippett Studio is strongly associated with character and creature work. Will you be doing more of these big environments in the future?

We are known for our rich history of animated creature work, but we’ve been doing environment work going back to The Matrix Revolutions, Constantine and Starship Troopers. However, that’s always viewed secondary to our creature work outside the studio.

During the last five years, we’ve really amped up our desire to accommodate more environmental work, and improved our pipeline accordingly. We have strong artistic vision and processes in place that allow us to bring large shots together quickly and flexibly, and we’re definitely looking to build on that more and more. The Shanghai flyover shot was a fantastic opportunity to prove that Tippett can quickly pull off crafted, large-scale environments without a creature in sight!

Currently we have a really exciting project in-house that involves flying over various incredibly dramatic landscapes, cloudscapes and cityscapes. All in all, it’s about five or six minutes of footage. It’s really fun stuff!

Did you draw any lessons from your work on The Crossing?

It was a whirlwind of an effort, and a lot of work came together very quickly. Some things we would do differently, of course, mostly in the area of what tech we would choose. The render tech we used on The Crossing was V-Ray and while it worked out incredibly well for us we’re currently looking into a program called Clarisse, which functions a lot like Katana, but with many more bells and whistles for environment work. It has everyone very excited.

Overall, I think everyone was really pleased with how smoothly the team worked together. We have experienced people in place who respect each other’s involvement, and I think we made all the right choices for the time and effort.

"The Crossing" poster

Special thanks to Niketa Roman. Images and video courtesy of Tippett Studio.

“Interstellar” Scientific Papers Published

Interstellar Black Hole - Double Negative

Lots of films employ scientific advisors. But rarely do the filmmakers end up advising the scientists.

However, that’s exactly what happened today, 13 February 2015, when the scientific paper “Gravitational Lensing by Spinning Black Holes in Astrophysics, and in the Movie Interstellar”, co-authored by Professor Kip Thorne and Double Negative’s Oliver James, Eugénie von Tunzelmann and Paul Franklin, was published in the Institute of Physics Publishing’s journal “Classical and Quantum Gravity”.

The paper describes the innovative computer code used to generate the film’s images of a wormhole and black hole, together with their backdrop of stars and nebulae. Using the code, the Double Negative team discovered that, when a camera is close to a rapidly-spinning black hole, spatial peculiarities known as caustics create multiple images of both individual stars and of the thin, bright plane of the galaxy in which the black hole resides. This is the first time the effects of caustics have been computed for a camera near a black hole.

In order to effectively visualise the caustic effects without unwanted flickering, the Double Negative team decided to abandon the standard rendering approach of using a single light ray for each pixel. Co-author of the study and chief scientist at Double Negative, Oliver James, explained:

“To get rid of the flickering and produce realistically smooth pictures for the movie, we changed our code in a manner that has never been done before. Instead of tracing the paths of individual light rays using Einstein’s equations—one per pixel—we traced the distorted paths and shapes of light beams.”

Co-author of the study, Kip Thorne, added:

“This new approach to making images will be of great value to astrophysicists like me. We, too, need smooth images.”

Oliver James continued:

“Once our code – Double Negative Gravitational Renderer (DNGR) – was mature and creating the images you see in the movie Interstellar, we realised we had a tool that could easily be adapted for scientific research.”

A second complementary paper by the same authors, “Visualizing Interstellar’s Wormhole”, is available on both the arXiv and Double Negative websites, and will be published soon in American Journal of Physics. It describes the creation of the Interstellar wormhole, and highlights the variety of study opportunities offered by the film for general relativity students.

“Life After Pi” Wins Documentary Award

Life After Pi Main Title

Life After Pi has won the award for Best Documentary Short Film at the 30th Annual Santa Barbara International Film Festival. Directed by Scott Leberecht and produced by Christina Lee Storm, the film chronicles the collapse of the visual effects studio Rhythm & Hues Studios in 2013. In a bitter twist of irony, even as news of the collapse was breaking, Rhythm and Hues won the Academy Award for its VFX work on Ang Lee’s Life of Pi.

Here’s what Cinefex founder, Don Shay, had to say about the film:

“Frank, but not inflammatory, Life After Pi takes us behind the scenes of the ironically-timed demise of Rhythm & Hues, and puts a very human face on an industry-wide tragedy that finds award-winning visual effects companies struggling to survive and talented effects artists leading migrant lives in search of gainful employment – all in crucial support of movies that make billions at the boxoffice.”

Speaking about the documentary’s award win, Leberecht said:

“As a twenty-year veteran of the visual effects industry, I am very happy that our film is being acknowledged and seen by so many. I carry a deep sense of gratitude for the brave individuals who participated in the film and went on record. For a brief moment, we broke through the culture of fear. My hope is that the conversation continues.”

Storm added:

“It’s a bittersweet win. We’re proud to have earned this recognition, but we’re also mindful of the human impact the events had upon the people featured in the movie, our co-workers and friends. We hope the film continues to shine a light and contribute to a better business model for all concerned in the film industry.”

Storm and Leberecht are currently developing a feature length documentary exploring the industry’s transition from optical to digital techniques in movie special effects. You can learn more about this – and Life After Pi – at the Hollywood Ending website.

The Making of “Alien Outpost”

"Alien Outpost" - the mothership attacks

Alien Outpost follows the fortunes of two documentary cameramen embedded in a USDF army unit at Outpost 37 – one of a dwindling number of military outposts built to defend the planet against an alien invasion that occurred ten years previously. With the war now over, both funding and support for these obsolete defences are in short supply, and all that remains is to mop up those aliens left behind after the departure of their mothership. But have the invaders – armoured giants known as Heavies – really retreated, or are they just biding their time before the next phase of the invasion begins?

Made on a budget of under $5 million and shot in the style of a military documentary – complete with cutaways to interviews with all the main protagonists – Alien Outpost is the feature directing debut of VFX supervisor Jabbar Raisani. The film contains 322 visual effects shots, delivered primarily by Hybride, where the key staff were Daniel Leduc, Pierre Raymond, Thierry Delattre and Philippe Theroux. Additional visual effects support was given by Craig Crawford at Cadence Effects, and individual artists Colin McCusker and Neall Stafford. Practical creature effects were the province of Alliance Studios.


In addition, a handful of effects shots were created by the director himself, who also served the film as production visual effects supervisor. “It was offered to me to have a VFX supervisor, but I said, you know what, let’s save the money and put it towards the actual shots, and I’ll take on the extra workload,” Raisani explained. “I ended up doing about a dozen shots myself, when we’d run out of money, but I knew we still had to do them!”

The Origins of Alien Outpost

"Alien Outpost" is the feature debut of VFX supervisor turned director, Jabbar Raisani.

“Alien Outpost” is the feature debut of VFX supervisor turned director, Jabbar Raisani.

Jabbar Raisani’s film career began at the age of 17, when a high school mentorship programme in his home state of Texas introduced him to visual effects and animation. After a stint at Atomic Pictures in San Antonio, he gained his first feature credit on Spykids 3-D: Game Over, working as a technical director for Janimation in Dallas. Following a move to Los Angeles, Raisani found employment at Stan Winston Studio, where he worked as both CG supervisor and previs artist on features including Fantastic Four, Eight Below and Iron Man.

It was while at Stan Winston Studio that Raisani first felt the urge to direct. “We were doing the practical suit for Iron Man,” he recalled. “At the time, Stan Winston Studio was sort of at the forefront of the rapid prototyping game, and we decided collectively that this would be the best way to do the suit.”

Remembering the day when Robert Downey Jr. first walked on to the Iron Man set wearing the partial suit, Raisani said, “Marvel had never seen him in the suit before. The director, Jon Favreau, had never seen him in the suit before. So it was really a tense moment. I found myself just watching Favreau work – you know, he totally owned that moment. He had Robert Downey walk around, he tried out camera angles – he just had such confidence. Watching Favreau do that, I was like, ‘Oh man, now that’s what I want to do!’”

A subsequent move to Robert Rodriguez’s Troublemaker Studios saw Raisani working as a visual effects supervisor on films including Machete and Predators. “I just pushed all the time to get on to set,” Raisani remarked, “and Robert Rodriguez gave me that chance.” After Predators, Raisani and another Troublemaker alumnus – Blake Clifton – returned to Los Angles to strike out on their own. “I wanted to direct films, and Blake wanted to be a cinematographer. So we started thinking about what was going to be our first feature.”

Drawing from their individual military backgrounds – and a shared love of military documentaries – Raisani and Clifton moved into an apartment and co-wrote the screenplay for Alien Outpost. “We had almost no furniture – a bed and a dresser each, and a television sitting on top of the box it came in. Oh, and two beanbags. All we did was watch movies and write.”

"Alien Outpost" was shot on location in South Africa.

“Alien Outpost” was co-written by Jabbar Raisani and Blake Clifton, and shot on a number of privately-owned farm locations in South Africa.

Building Outpost 37

Alien Outpost was shot in South Africa, on a small number of locations approximately 30 minutes’ drive from Johannesburg. Getting clearance to shoot a film full of firefights and pyrotechnics proved more difficult than the filmmakers had anticipated. “The first location we chose was a national park,” Raisani recalled. “At first they said, ‘Oh yeah – lots of people film commercials in here.’ So we met the park ranger and walked out to the place where I wanted to build the Outpost. I told him there were going to be explosions and gunfire, but said that we would not actually damage anything. He stopped me in mid-conversation and said, ‘I just want you to be aware that I’m uncomfortable even with how far we’ve walked on the grass here.”

With permission refused to film in the national park, the production team began investigating alternatives. “We found a farm that was privately owned – what in Texas I would call a ranch,” said Raisani. “It turned out that the guy who managed it was really into visual effects. So he and I kind of hit it off. I told him, ‘If you let us shoot here, I’ll put you in the film.’ And he was game.”

Other locations – including a quarry, a deserted village and the valley in which the film’s final confrontation would play out – were found nearby, each no more than 15 minutes’ drive from the farm, which would also function as the production’s base camp.

The large ensemble cast were put through a week of boot camp before shooting began, during which they were required to stay in character at all times.

The large ensemble cast were put through a week of boot camp before shooting began, during which they were required to stay in character at all times.

Before shooting began, the actors spent a week together on location, familiarising themselves with the environment and getting into character. “We did a week of boot camp,” Raisani confirmed. “All the guys were there from sunrise to sunset, and they had to stay in their ranks. We had a military advisor, and he ensured that each of them knew what their rank was, and how they worked in the hierarchy. They really fell into it.”

Raisani encouraged the actors to stay in role throughout the production by maintaining an open set. “A lot of guys spent a lot of time on set. I said, ‘Look, if any of you guys want to be there, you can be there. The more people on camera, the cooler this is going to look, and the more it’s going to feel like you guys really are together out there.’ Some of the scenes were very character-specific, but otherwise if they wanted to be there, they could absolutely be there.”

Creating the Aliens


Production designer Eddie Yang was responsible for the overall look of the film, from the run-down Outpost 37, around which much of the action is centred, to the alien Heavies and their associated technology. For the Heavies specifically, Yang worked hand-in-hand with Steve Wang, who led the Stan Winston Studio design team behind the iconic alien hunter in Predator.

“The idea was to have a future that’s based in reality,” Raisani remarked. “When the Heavies attacked, they decimated our ability to produce new things. So a lot of the human tech is the same as what we have now. Part of that was budgetary. If I could have built all kinds of brand new, cool, futuristic vehicles, I would have explored that more. But we knew it wasn’t feasible.”

Alien-Outpost-Design-2Yang and Wang turned to a number of reference sources for the aliens, including video games and films, as well as nature. “We looked at a lot of reptilian photographs,” commented Raisani, “particularly turtles and lizards – they were a big inspiration for the Heavy.”

While the designers explored a number of radical body shapes, the final Heavy design was a more conventional, lizard-like biped. “We tried something with multiple legs,” said Raisani. “We even had one whose bottom part was a snake. But ultimately I knew I wanted a guy in a suit. I come from a practical effects background, so I know that doing it that way is very cost-effective in the places where you can get away with it. Also, if you have the suit there in the plate, it’s perfect lighting reference.”

Initial Heavy designs took the form of sketches in both 2D and 3D, with the designers working primarily in Photoshop and ZBrush. From there, the team at Alliance Studios – a creature and make-up effects company newly set up by Yang and Wang – sculpted the creature in clay and took moulds. “They pulled foam rubber suits from the mould, and then airbrushed them,” Raisani explained. “The suit had a self-actuating jaw, which attached directly to the jaw of the suit performer, Doug Tate. When Doug opened his mouth, the mouth opened; when he closed his mouth, it closed.”

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

The USDF troops have their first close encounter with the Heavies when they leave Outpost 37 to investigate allegations that one of their mortar rounds has hit the nearby village of Ghrem. While exploring a quarry littered with dead goats, they are ambushed by the waiting aliens.

“We had Doug Tait there in the suit all day,” Raisani recounted. “It was really rough terrain, so I knew it would be problematic having him take the suit on and off. We scouted all the places where he would appear, and then slotted our day based on the knowledge that it would take him roughly twenty minutes to move from place to place. We would do a shot of the Heavy, and then while he was moving location, we would be filming down in the quarry. So we were leapfrogging back and forth.”

Performer Doug Tait wore the Heavy suit, created by Alliance Studios, in all the scenes featuring the alien invaders.

Performer Doug Tait wore the Heavy suit, created by Alliance Studios, for most of the scenes featuring the alien invaders.

On a separate day, Raisani set up a rolling greenscreen shoot of Tait performing in the suit, in natural light. “We did a shot every half-hour throughout the day, when we knew we didn’t need the Heavy for anything else. That gave us a kind of library of elements to use later in post, with different actions and lighting.”

While most of the scenes featuring the alien Heavies were shot using Tait in the suit, many of the shots were augmented digitally. For some shots, the Heavy was replaced entirely by its digital counterpart.

Digital enhancements to the Heavy suit included a wider range of facial expressions and an additional reversed leg joint. In some scenes, Hybride replaced the suit entirely by its digital counterpart.

Digital enhancements to the Heavy suit included a wider range of facial expressions and an additional reversed leg joint. In some scenes, Hybride replaced the suit entirely by its digital counterpart.

“We knew he was going to be augmented from the beginning,” Raisani commented. “Given the budget, we knew we could afford one practical Heavy with a helmet and removable armour, which would give us multiple configurations. But we knew we couldn’t make the eyes move. We actually ended up adjusting the suit a little bit more than planned. We made a decision in post to give it a leg like a dog, which meant that in any scene where you see its bottom half, we had to adjust the legs to the new shape.”

The digital Heavy was based on a 3D scan of the suit. “We scanned the entire suit in LA, but decided to use our unit photographer for the texture shoot to reduce the cost,” Raisani recalled. “The resulting OBJ files, along with the raw data, all went up to Hybride.” Shots featuring the digital Heavy were modelled and animated in Autodesk Softimage and rendered out using Solid Angle Arnold.

Watch a video breakdown reel of visual effects from Alien Outpost:

Fire and Fights

The ambush in the quarry is just one of many firefights in Alien Outpost. Every shot featuring pyrotechnics – with the exception of a fully digital shot which comes at the film’s climax – began with a practical effect. Each the time the weapons of the Heavies came into play, however, digital enhancements were used to give them a suitably alien edge.

“When the Heavies’ weapons go off, I wanted blue energy tied in with that,” Raisani explained. “We did some tests, but actually having blue explosions is really difficult, both in terms of safety and the availability of materials. So we started with a real explosion, then Hybride went in and added a digital explosion that matched the timing of the practical one.”

With the exception of one fully digital explosion, all the pyrotechnics seen in "Alien Outpost" had a practical base.

With the exception of one fully digital explosion, all the pyrotechnics seen in “Alien Outpost” had a practical base.

The more conventional tracer fire seen throughout the action was created by UK-based visual effects artist Colin McCusker – with whom Raisani had worked previously on Game of Thrones.

Despite the “make do and mend” philosophy of their war-torn world, the USDF troops do have access to one piece of futuristic technology: their guns are loaded with High Impact Phosphorus Rounds (HIPR), otherwise known as “Reds”. The bullets have an outer armour-piercing case, which contains a second round whose purpose is to inject incendiaries directly into the enemy’s body. “The Reds are very high-tech,” Raisani confirmed, “although there’s nothing really radical that happens with them visually … except for when they explode.”

During one of the gun battles, a human insurgent is blown apart by one of the high-impact Reds. “We shot a stunt guy running up the hill with practical squibs on, shooting blood out,” Raisani stated. “Then we put a dummy out there, filled it with explosives and blew it apart. Hybride combined the two shots together, and added some digital gore.”

Outpost 37 Stills 2013

For a scene in which an insurgent is hit by an incendiary round, a dummy was filled with explosives and blown apart. Hybride combined the shot digitally with footage of a stuntman running into position, and enhanced it with digital gore.

A similar approach was used for a scene in which a captured Heavy is shot in the head at point-blank range: “Doug Tait did a performance in the suit of the Heavy dying, and then we shot a rig covered in blood bags that we exploded on camera. Again, Hybride did a digital blend and added gore.”

Additional gore effects can be seen in a scene where one of the USDF soldiers slashes the neck of an insurgent. The performer playing the victim wore a prosthetic fitted with a practical blood rig, while his attacker mimed the cutting action. Cadence Effects completed the effect by adding a digital blade to the practical knife hilt.

Seeing in the Dark

At key points in the story, important action is seen playing out on computer monitors, using either thermal or night vision. The thermal footage was shot for real using a heat-sensitive camera. With the exception of the screen on the thermal camera itself, all the monitor displays were tracked in during post-production.

“I worked on Predators, and although we did some real stuff for the Predators’ vision, most of it ended up being done digitally, and for me it just never looks the same,” Raisani confessed. “So I said, ‘Look, we have to have a thermal camera there every single day.’ We had a guy shooting in tandem with us; there are also some shots where the actors playing the journalists had the real thermal camera.”

A different approach was taken with the night vision. “The helicopter night vision was done by Cadence Effects,” Raisani revealed. “We had a little drone with a camera, and we put it everything through Nuke to make it look like night vision.”

Monitor screens featuring both real thermal imagery and simulated night vision were shot separately and composited into the live action plates during post-production.

Monitor screens featuring both real thermal imagery and simulated night vision were shot separately and composited into the live action plates during post-production.

The Spire

The film’s finale sees the USDF soldiers confronting both Heavies and their mind-controlled human minions in the shadow of a mysterious alien structure known as the Spire. While the Spire was a largely digital construct, strategically-positioned set pieces aided its integration into the environment. “We realised the landscape had nowhere for the bad guys to hide,” Raisani explained. “So we built these cubes, which we integrated into the design of the Spire. We worked a dozen or so of the cubes into the landscape, then Hybride worked those practical elements into the design.”

A similar approach was used for later scenes set inside the Spire. “The bottom ten feet of the Spire interior was a practical build, using the same cubes, because I knew that I didn’t want to have to extend the set for every shot,” commented Raisani. “We moved the cubes from shot to shot, so it would feel like the whole room was filled with them. Craig Crawford at Cadence Effects did some very simple digital augmentation: a light flicker with a little movement in it, and Hybride did a wide shot. But it was 90% there in-camera.”

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

After the Battle

In a brief post-credits scene, the surviving members of the Outpost 37 team are seen embarking on their next operation. Andros (Reiley McClendon), who loses his hand during the film’s final battle, is seen wearing a prosthetic replacement. “Eddie Yang sculpted the hand digitally, and we rapid-prototyped the digital parts and joined all the mechanisms together,” Raisani explained. “It was kind of a puppet – like those little elasticated figurines where you push on the base and the whole thing collapses, then you let off the pressure and the whole thing pops back up. When you see Andros closing the prosthetic hand, Eddie’s just off-camera acting as puppeteer.”

Another character sports a prosthetic leg to replace the limb he lost in action. “That was done sort of old-school,” said Raisani. “The actor is just sitting on top of his own leg. For the replacement leg, Eddie just bought someone’s prosthetic leg in South Africa on the internet. It belonged to someone’s relative who had died. It cost about 50 bucks.”

A moment of rare calm in "Alien Outpost"

Reflections on Alien Outpost

Jabbar Raisani is one of a number of visual effects artist who have recently turned their hands to writing and directing. The highest profile example is perhaps Gareth Edwards, whose indie film Monsters led to his taking the helm on the 2014 big-budget reboot of Godzilla. At the same time, crowdsourcing has enabled other effects professionals to get their own feature projects into production.

“I think this is probably a trend,” Raisani opined. “There is more visual effects in film nowadays, which means guys like me are getting more control on set, and we’re naturally falling more and more into a directorial seat. I ended up doing a lot of second unit stuff before I even knew really what directing was. If you have a passion for storytelling, I think it’s a natural progression towards directing your own material.”

With his first feature under his belt, Raisani is already planning more films, including an additional three set in the same world as Alien Outpost. “The second one picks up close to where this one finishes,” he revealed. “There’s a third, which is really the end of the story, and then we’re coming back around for a prequel. So if everyone likes this one – and if all the numbers come back the way they should – then I think it’s likely there will be a follow-up.”

Other films in development include Capturing the Dead, a horror film co-written with Blake Clifton, and Pulse, adapted by Raisani from the novel by Jeremy Robinson. “When you’re setting out as a director – and maybe forever – you’ve got to have three or four projects all on the move,” Raisani reflected. “Then you just have to follow the heat. Whichever one gets steaming: go with it!”

“As for Alien Outpost, I feel really good about it. It’s one of the most difficult things that I’ve ever done, but equally one of the most rewarding. At the end of the day it’s the movie I wanted to make.”

Jabbar Raisani and Blake Clifton with the cast of "Alien Outpost"

Jabbar Raisani and Blake Clifton with the cast of “Alien Outpost”

Special thanks to Craig Bankey and Laurie Cook. Alien Outpost photographs and video copyright © 2015 O37 Films Limited.

“Interstellar” Wins VFX BAFTA

Christopher Nolan’s space epic Interstellar picked up the 2015 BAFTA Award for Special Visual Effects, in a star-studded ceremony held last night, 8 February 2015, at the Royal Opera House in London’s Covent Garden.

Co-written by Nolan and brother Jonathan, the film is a journey of discovery, realised in part through stunning visual effects images created by Double Negative. As he had with the Dark Knight trilogy and other films, however, Nolan sought to capture as much action as possible in-camera, with on-set special effects orchestrated by Scott Fisher, and other practical effects by New Deal Studios.

Picking up the award were visual effects supervisor Paul Franklin, nominated along with Scott Fisher, Andrew Lockley and Ian Hunter. You’ll find extensive coverage of their work on the film in Cinefex issue 140. It goes without saying that we think it’s a great read, but don’t take our word for it – here’s the proof that BAFTA-winner Paul Franklin agrees:

Paul Franklin of Cinefex 140

Caesar Rules at the 13th Annual VES Awards

13th Annual VES AwardsLast night – February 4, 2015 – the Visual Effects Society held the 13th Annual VES Awards in recognition of outstanding visual effects artistry and innovation in film, animation, television, commercials, video games and special venues.

Disney’s Big Hero 6 scooped no less than five awards not only in a range of animated features categories, but notably too in the “Outstanding Model in any Motion Media Project” category, earning plaudits for the metropolitan mash-up that is the City of San Fransokyo. Meanwhile, Game of Thrones burned up the television categories, collecting three awards, including “Outstanding Visual Effects in a Visual Effects-Driven Photoreal/Live Action Broadcast Program”, for the season 4 finale, The ChildrenCaesar - "Dawn of the Planet of the Apes"

The big winner out of the competing feature films was Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, with Weta Digital’s VFX team, led by Joe Letteri, picking up the award for “Outstanding Visual Effects in a Visual Effects-Driven Photoreal/Live Action Feature Motion Picture”.

While the film’s simian star, Caesar, was not there to collect the award in person, his performance brought more plaudits in the form of the award for “Outstanding Performance of an Animated Character in a Photoreal/Live Action Feature Motion Picture”. And all those seamless shots of apes in the rain earned the film’s compositing team the award for “Outstanding Compositing in a Photoreal/Live Action Feature Motion Picture”.

Quicksilver - "X-Men: Days of Future Past"Additional feature awards went to the time-warping Quicksilver kitchen sequence from X-Men: Days of Future Past, and the invisible effects of Birdman, while a host of further awards were handed out to winners in the fields of commercials, video games and special venues.

For a full list of all the winners, and a gallery of photos from the night, visit the VES website.

“Dawn of the Planet of the Apes” and “X-Men: Days of Future Past” photographs courtesy of Weta Digital and Rising Sun Pictures and copyright © 2014 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved.

The Cinefex Awards 2014

The Cinefex Awards 2014

Never mind the Oscars. In the world of visual effects, there’s only one awards ceremony that counts: the Cinefex Awards.

Yes, the time has come once more for us Cinefex staffers to set aside our famed objectivity, take off our research journalist hats, and tell the world not what’s in our heads, but in our hearts.

Votes have been cast in a number of cunningly devised VFX categories. So, without further ado, here are the results of the 2nd Annual Cinefex Awards!

Cinefex Awards - Jaw on the Floor

The “Jaw On The Floor” Award … goes to the VFX that left us totally amazed

WINNER – Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

Jody Duncan – “Not being an inherently ‘techie’ person, the effects that always amaze me most are those that hit me in the gut, that affect me emotionally. So my Jaw on the Floor Award has to go to the closeups on Caesar and his son, Blue Eyes, in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, which were so expressive and pain-filled, I totally forgot that I was looking at computer generated characters.”

Don Shay – “First Gollum. Then Kong. Now Caesar. For more than a decade, Weta has been advancing the art of character creation via the merger of motion capture technology and computer animation. Each project has been wondrous to behold, culminating with Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, in which brain-boosted apes give performances as moving and powerful as their human counterparts. Maybe more. Forget the debate over who’s most responsible for these performances – Andy Serkis and his mocap army or the artists at Weta Digital – this is an awesome blend of art and technology that invites one to look past the artifice of these characters and into their souls.”

Joe Fordham – “Dawn of the Planet of the Apes was a film that exceeded my expectations in just about every way. Despite a preview screening of some early scenes at Fox – and the amazing experience of attending a scoring session for the movie – I was not prepared for the emotional wallop that the film delivered. Damn, was it gorgeous to look at, with its bedraggled rainforest and ruined San Francisco. Most importantly, it worked as a character piece. I cared for those apes, and ceased to think of them as anything but empathic, conflicted and emotional creatures. The visual effects were an organic part of all the film, and that’s really what it’s all about.”

Gregg Shay – “My winner is Dawn of the Planet of the Apes. Weta Digital (with Standard Deviation) has absolutely figured out how to transform a human actor into a CG character. I totally bought into the apes being apes, and Andy Serkis and Toby Kebell gave wonderful performances. Oh, and I loved the movie too!”

Graham Edwards – “They talk about how hard it is to cross the uncanny valley. Well, in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, Caesar and his simian sidekicks swung clear to the other side on rainforest vines. The apes in this movie are a true quantum leap in digital character creation – and deliver emotional performances to boot. Disbelief suspended. An out-and-out VFX win.”

Cinefex Awards - What Did I Just See?

The “What Did I Just See?” Award … goes to the invisible VFX we didn’t even spot

WINNER – Birdman

Joe Fordham – “For reasons too complicated to explain, we had a revolving door on the editorial lineup for Cinefex 140, so at one point I was excited to be covering Alejandro Iñárritu’s Birdman. Without telling tales out of school, I can say with some authority that the visual effects are some of the most cunningly devised I’ve seen (or not seen) in a while. However, despite one sequence where the film delves into full-bore fantasy – terrific work by Rodeo FX and Spectral Motion – the real pyrotechnics in this film are in the performances. I found the unsavory nature of these self-possessed theatre folk very funny … and astonishingly we witness these damaged people backbiting, weeping and clawing at each other for what appears to be one unbroken 85-minute take. I thought it was a masterpiece.”

Gregg Shay – “Marvel’s Captain America: The Winter Soldier featured an unbelievable 2,500 effects shots. That’s more than Avengers Assemble. I think I must have missed at least 500 of them!”

Graham Edwards – “LAIKA’s latest animated feature may not seem like an obvious candidate for this award, but for the entire time I was watching The Boxtrolls, I completely failed to spot the places where the practical stagework of the stop-motion animation ended, and the seamlessly integrated CG effects began.”

Cinefex Awards - Hmm, That's New

The “Hmm, That’s New” Award … goes to the most innovative VFX

WINNER – Captain America: The Winter Soldier

Gregg Shay – “Lola VFX had to get creative for the ‘Old Peggy’ shots in Captain America: The Winter Soldier. After shooting scenes with actress Hayley Atwell without old age makeup, they shot an elderly lookalike’s face in their face-projection rig, and projected parts of it on to the original photography.”

Joe Fordham – “Jonathan Glazer’s Under the Skin haunted me. The moment that the alien, played by Scarlett Johansson, takes her human victims back to ‘her place’ and has her way with them ranks as some of the most disturbing imagery I’ve seen in a science fiction film. But it’s kind of beautiful at the same time. Hats off to production designer Chris Oddy, Asylum Models and Effects and visual effects supervisors Tom Debenham and Dominic Parker at One of Us. You truly freaked me out.”

Graham Edwards – “It’s hard to come up with a new design for a movie alien. Edge of Tomorrow did a pretty terrific job, so I’ve no hesitation in voting for it here. The fluid, unpredictable forms of the Mimics – the result of extensive development work by production designer Oliver Scholl and a bunch of artists including Kevin Jenkins, Steve Burg, Ed Natividad and Tani Kunitake, interpreted and realised by the VFX teams at Framestore and MPC – were startling to look at, unpredictable in their behaviour and like nothing I’d seen before.”

Cinefex Awards - Olide But Goodie

The “Oldie But Goodie” Award … goes to the best use of old-school visual effects

WINNER – Interstellar

Don Shay – “Old-school visual effects were in short supply this year, so let’s raise a toast to Christopher Nolan, whose Interstellar – sprawling in scope and theme – would almost certainly have been an orgy of digital excess in the hands of most other directors. Not to belittle the significant digital accomplishments of the film, but Nolan kept his pixels in a supporting role, enhancing his preferred use of practical effects, full-size spacecraft and robots, elegant miniatures and exotic ‘alien’ locations. On film, no less. And in doing so, he created an epic space adventure, rooted in physical and scientific reality, that speaks to both the heart and the mind.”

Gregg Shay – “The physical models built by New Deal Studios for Interstellar dovetailed seamlessly with Double Negative’s digital work. It’s wonderful to see effective – and believable – practical work on today’s big budget films.”

Jody Duncan – “When Paul Franklin and Ian Hunter told me how they did the shots of a spaceship traveling through a black hole in Interstellar, I felt as if I’d been transported back to the early days of Cinefex magazine. They planted an honest-to-goodness practical miniature spaceship on the ground, nose up, and photographed it as they dropped honest-to-goodness STUFF on it! Was this Gene Warren of Fantasy II talking circa 1981? Could it be that someone actually created such imagery without a particle system in 2014? Fantastic!”

Joe Fordham – “ My vote goes to Interstellar. Bless them for doing so much for real, and kudos to all for making such impressive use of those practical elements.”

Graham Edwards – “Tempting though it is to honour the charming models and matte paintings seen in The Grand Budapest Hotel, I’m siding with Interstellar, for two reasons. One: it’s heart-warming to see traditional spacecraft miniatures holding their own in this digital age. Two: while I was watching the movie, I didn’t give two hoots what I was looking at – all I knew was that the story was sweeping me along and the whole thing looked breathtakingly good!”

Cinefex Awards - Eye Candy

The “Eye Candy” Award … goes to the VFX that looked plain gorgeous

WINNER – Guardians of the Galaxy

Graham Edwards – “Ever since I bought my first book of paintings by artist Chris Foss, I’ve been a sucker for big, gaudy spaceships. That’s why my winner in this category is the big, gaudy Guardians of the Galaxy.”

Gregg Shay – “The visuals throughout the whole of Guardians of the Galaxy were stunning. I was impressed by the look of all of the characters and creatures, the environments and the spaceships. The film also featured some amazing makeup work.”

Don Shay – “Does the world need another ‘reimagined’ fairy tale in which the original villain is now the misunderstood hero – or heroine? Not in my view. So, though I was less than enthralled with the character motivation and logic-defying storyline of Maleficent, I was nonetheless enchanted by the imaginative visuals and look of the film. Every frame looks like the most beautifully rendered storybook you’ve ever seen. High marks to Robert Stromberg – former matte artist, visual effects supervisor, Oscar-winning production designer and now first-time director. Happily, his debut feature was a home run at the box office, surely guaranteeing him another time at bat. I want to see what he does next.”

Joe Fordham – “I’m going with Dawn of the Planet of the Apes for this award. I loved those soggy apes.”

Cinefex Awards - Big Cheesy Grin

The “Big Cheesy Grin” Award … goes to the VFX moment that made us feel like kids again

WINNER – Guardians of the Galaxy

Jody Duncan – “My vote goes to Rocket, the genetically engineered raccoon, in Guardians of the Galaxy. Whether it was Rocket himself or the fantastic soundtrack (which was essentially the soundtrack of my teen years) that made me feel like a kid again, I’m not sure, but that furry ball of Ones and Zeroes had more personality, heart and humor than many of the human performances I’ve seen this year!”

Graham Edwards – “From Peter Quill’s enterprising employment of an alien rodent as a microphone, to the brilliant interplay between Rocket Raccoon and Groot, to the crowd-pleasing moment when umpty-thousand Nova Corps Starblasters hook up to form a gigantic protective net over their beleagured planet … Guardians of the Galaxy delivered big-screen space opera hokum on a scale both epic and human, supported throughout by colourful and perfectly pitched visual effects.”

Joe Fordham – “The docking sequence in Interstellar was, for me, the most thrilling moment of visual effects cinema last year. I loved how Nolan staged the preceding turning point in the narrative in a very matter-of-fact manner – making it all the more shocking. The subsequent mating of the Ranger and Endurance spacecraft was, to me, electrifying. In fact, there were many moments in the film that held me in their thrall: the first journey into the wormhole, the discovery of the ice planet, the Tesseract and the moment of the hand reaching out to Brand … *sniffle*”

Don Shay – “This is an easy one. At a critical juncture in X-Men: Days of Future Past, the labyrinthine plot calls for Wolverine and the X-Men to free their old rival, Magneto, from confinement in an iron-free, impregnable vault deep beneath the Pentagon. What’s a mutant to do? Why, bring in Quicksilver to penetrate the fortress and – quite literally – run circles around Magneto’s helpless-to-stop-him security detail. Real-time slows to a virtual stop as the camera follows the hyper-fast Quicksilver, who scampers about like Road Runner on steroids, playfully art-directing and tweaking the mayhem he’s creating. Audaciously conceived and executed – and pretty darn funny.”

Janine Pourroy – “I thought Edge of Tomorrow was terrific. I actually forgot about the effects and fell into the story, which is always a blessing these days.”

Gregg Shay – “Who doesn’t love watching Godzilla destroy cities around the world? And in this year’s Godzilla, directed by Gareth Edwards, the iconic lizard was bigger and better than ever.”

Cinefex Awards - The One That Got Away

The “One That Got Away” Award … goes to the best VFX in a film we didn’t cover

WINNER – Birdman

Joe Fordham – “For the reasons I’ve already explained, my vote goes to Birdman.”

Graham Edwards – “Controversially, I’m casting my vote for a film which, at the time of writing, I confess I haven’t seen, since they only just saw fit to release it in the UK. Birdman is a film that everyone’s talking about, and I’ve listened to enough of the chatter to know that if there’s one film I really wish I could have read about in Cinefex during 2014, it’s this one.”

Don Shay – “The film I most regret our not having covered recently is Kon Tiki, a criminally underseen gem that I caught up with only recently on video. In 1947, Thor Heyerdahl and five colleagues set out to prove that people from South America first inhabited Polynesia – 5,000 miles away and 1,500 years ago – by casting themselves onto the high seas on a raft of the sort that these primitive explorers could have built. Kon-Tiki, a gripping re-enactment of the Heyerdahl expedition, features some of the best ocean-based visual effects I’ve seen – including tumultuous storms and thrilling encounters with whales and sharks. And they were done, not by one of the big-name visual effects companies, as one might expect from the quality of the work, but by a handful of small Scandinavian companies that proved themselves fully capable – if you’ll pardon the expression – of blowing the big guys out of the water.”

Cinefex Awards - Never Mind the VFX

And finally … The “Never Mind The VFX” Award … goes to simply the best movie of the year

WINNER – The Grand Budapest Hotel

Janine Pourroy – “I fell in love with The Grand Budapest Hotel, which I continue to watch again and again, almost compulsively, finding new things to admire about it each time: its delightful color palette, its wonderful Wes Anderson-y setups, its perfect use of miniatures, its marvelous script, as delivered by Ralph Fiennes. Capturing the zeitgeist of a very specific time and place is something that Wes Anderson does better than anybody else. It’s like magic to me.”

Joe Fordham – “Boyhood and The Grand Budapest Hotel were the films that gave me the biggest charge in the cinema last year. But Dawn of the Planet of the Apes and Interstellar also linger in my imagination.”

Graham Edwards – “I’m tempted to vote for Under the Skin, a dark and disturbing sci-fi film with a riveting – and heavily improvised – central performance from Scarlett Johansson. It mesmerised me from start to finish, and creeped me out more than any other film I can remember in recent years. Instead, I’m going for the opposite extreme and backing the frothy delight that is The Grand Budapest Hotel. I think I grinned from start to finish, and thinking about the film now I’m grinning all over again.”

Don Shay – “Easily topping my list of the best films of the year is Birdman. The film – co-written and directed by Alejandro González Iñárritu and with an exhilarating performance by Michael Keaton – defies description in a mere sentence or two, but richly deserves the accolades it has garnered. Technically virtuosic, it is staged and photographed, via fine-tuned choreography and artful digital stitching of long-take scenes, to seem as though all but one brief segment has been captured in a single continuous take. Brilliant on all accounts.”

Jody Duncan – “I have to confess that my REAL favorite movie of the year was Begin Again … with not an effects shot to be found.”

That concludes the Cinefex Awards 2014. Now it’s over to you. Tell us which movie moment put your jaw on the floor, which film you wish we’d covered, and which movie showed you something you’d never seen before. Oh, and while you’re at it, just how big was that cheesy grin of yours?

Write a comment below, or vote for your favourite film from the following list of the collective winners of the 2nd Annual Cinefex Awards.

Special thanks to the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man.