D is for Dinosaur

by Graham Edwards

VFX ABC - D is for DinosaurIn the VFX ABC, the letter “D” stands for “Dinosaur”.

The word “dinosaur” was coined by Victorian naturalist Sir Richard Owen in 1841. Derived from the Greek, it means “terrible lizard”.

The modern meaning is, of course, “humongous slavering monster that tramples the getaway car, eats the supporting actor and fills the IMAX screen from top to bottom.”

As well as giving dinosaurs their name, Owen was one of the first to recognise their entertainment potential. In 1852, following London’s Great Exhibition, he oversaw the creation of 33 life-size concrete dinosaur sculptures. After the giant models had been artistically placed in parkland surrounding Crystal Palace, Owen hosted a flamboyant dinner party inside the hollow mould that had been used to make the Iguanodon.

After that, dinosaurs swiftly rampaged through popular culture, including early cinema. In 1925, Willis O’Brien – one of the earliest visual effects practitioners – chose them as a subject for his revolutionary stop motion animation techniques in The Lost World, a film which took Owen’s Victorian concept of the dinosaur tableau and made it live and breathe.

Willis O'Brien and a dinosaur from "The Lost World"

Willis O’Brien and a dinosaur from “The Lost World”

For nearly seventy years, stop motion remained the technique of choice for bringing extinct creatures to life. In 1953, The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms saw Ray Harryhausen using O’Brien’s methods to resurrect a long-dormant Rhedosaurus – a fictional dinosaur awoken from its slumber by an A-bomb test.

More Harryhausen dinosaurs followed in 1966, when One Million Years B.C. showcased his Dynamation process in glorious Technicolor. Three years later, he repeated the trick yet again with The Valley of Gwangi. Impressive though Gwangi’s dinosaurs were, the film ultimately lacked the box office bite of its prehistoric predecessor (perhaps because it swapped Raquel Welch in a leather bikini for a bunch of cowboys).

The Rhedosaurus from "The Beast From 20,000 Fathoms"

The Rhedosaurus from “The Beast From 20,000 Fathoms”

Stop motion may have been king of the dinosaur world, but moving a complex puppet frame by frame is time-consuming … and therefore expensive. And you know movie producers: they’re always looking for ways to cut corners. Enter the “slurpasaur” (AKA a lizard in a dinosaur suit).

One of the earliest slurpasaurs appears in The Mysterious Island, made just four years after The Lost World. You can almost hear the conversation during the preproduction meeting:

“Hey guys, is this dinosaur going to be an animated model?”
“Nah, let’s just stick a plastic horn on a baby alligator.”

Slurpasaurs continued to offer a low-rent alternative to stop motion dinosaurs into the ’50s and ’60s. Even the great Willis O’Brien found himself consulting on costumed iguanas for the 1960 remake of The Lost World – a far from satisfying experience for the master of stop motion. (Did Obie ever actual lower himself to getting hands-on with a slurpasaur? I’m not sure. If you know, leave a comment below and tell me all about it!) 

Slurpasaurs battle in "The Lost World" (1960)

Slurpasaurs battle in “The Lost World” (1960)

As you’ve probably realised, in tracking the evolution of movie dinosaurs, we are in fact dissecting the DNA of a much broader subject: creature effects. Name a technique, and I guarantee it’s been used to make a dinosaur. Man in a suit? Check. While you might associate this option with such flops as The Last Dinosaur or Baby: The Secret of the Lost Legend, how about all those Godzilla movies? (Was Godzilla a dinosaur? Discuss.) Nor should we forget the amazing Velociraptor suits created by Stan Winston Studio for Jurassic Park and its sequels.

Stan Winston Studio's velociraptor suit - "Jurassic Park"

Stan Winston Studio’s velociraptor suit from “Jurassic Park”

How about puppetry and animatronics? Check again. The challenge of making mechanical monsters was taken up in the 1970s by Roger Dicken in a series of Amicus productions including The Land That Time Forgot. The results may not be VFX gold but, when viewed with a few beers inside you, they’re entertaining enough. Some years later, Doug Beswick made a valiant attempt to resurrect the technique by creating a rod-puppet tyrannosaur for My Science Project (unfortunately, the puppeteers never got the rehearsal time they needed to do Beswick’s impressive miniature justice).

The Land That Time Forgot

“The Land That Time Forgot”

Most film directors prefer to have their performers on set. The sheer size of your average dinosaur has always made that a literally enormous challenge. Many of the films I’ve mentioned saw hapless actors stuffed into full-size replicas of chomping jaws, but it was Stan Winston who finally achieved the impossible when he populated Jurassic Park with full-scale dinosaurs that not only looked stunning, but delivered great performances too.

Jurassic Park also drew a line in the digital sand, heralding the arrival of the truly convincing CG creature. When Dr Alan Grant (Sam Neill) got his first view of a Brachiosaurus and exclaimed, “It’s a dinosaur!” I believed him, and I’ll bet you did too. And by the time the Tyrannosaurus Rex brought the house down at the climax of the film, I was ready to agree that dinosaurs really do rule the Earth.

ILM's digital T-Rex from "Jurassic Park"

ILM’s digital T-Rex from “Jurassic Park”

Jurassic Park spawned two sequels that steadily upped the ante in both the digital and animatronic arenas. The third movie features a stunning fight between a T-Rex and a Spinosaurus which, for my money, still stands as the definitive dino dust-off. Since then, you could be forgiven for thinking dinosaurs have become extinct all over again (unless you count the mediocre monsters served up by cash-ins like Carnosaur and Dinosaur Island, or the endless stream of straight-to-SyFy flicks with titles like Nuclear Tyrannoshark or Crocoraptor).

Full-scale T-Rex and Spinosaurus by Stan Winston Studio, as seen in "Jurassic Park III"

Full-scale T-Rex and Spinosaurus by Stan Winston Studio, as seen in “Jurassic Park III”

But you can’t keep a good dinosaur down. This year brought a whole new generation of prehistoric critters to our screens with Walking With Dinosaurs 3D. While this family-friendly film barely snatched a Rotten Tomatoes score of 25%, Marco Marenghi, Animation Director at Animal Logic, calls their work on the film “game-changing”. A new automated muscle system called Steroid took over control of the interaction between the dinosaurs’ skin and the internal anatomy, with a second system called RepTile taking care of skin and scales. Read more about Animal Logic’s work on the film on their website.

Animal Logic's state-of-the-art dinosaurs from "Walking With Dinosaurs 3D"

Animal Logic’s state-of-the-art dinosaurs from “Walking With Dinosaurs 3D” (Image: Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation)

And there’s more to come: Jurassic World is scheduled for a summer 2015 release with ILM and Tippett Studio partnering up to deliver the dinosaurs. I’ve no idea what sort of reptilian revolution they have up their sleeves, but here are three of my personal predictions:

  • Flesh … As Animal Logic have shown us, the beauty of the very latest digital creatures is more than just skin deep. Life of Pi gave us a tiger whose muscles tense in anticipation of its every move. In The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, the titular dragon boasts a virtually complete anatomy moving under that scaly skin. I’m in no doubt the dinosaurs of Jurassic World will be fleshed out like no other prehistoric creatures we’ve seen before.
  • Science … Taking its lead from the Michael Crichton novel on which it was based, Jurassic Park based its dinosaur designs on cutting edge scientific thinking, imagining warm-blooded, intelligent creatures that ran in herds, looked after their young and hunted in packs. If Jurassic World takes account of recent archeological developments, we’re likely to see even more emphasis on interesting behavioural traits. We may see some very big dinosaurs … perhaps even some very, very big dinosaurs. And, despite recent heated debate on the subject, I suspect we may see at least one dinosaur with feathers.
  • Awe … Taking an audience’s breath away is a tall order. Jurassic Park did it by showing us something we’d never seen before. I want Jurassic World to do the same. I want beautiful dinosaurs that really tickle my sense of wonder … as well as delivering that special thrill you get when the object in the mirror really is closer than it appears.

None of us really knows what the future holds for movie dinosaurs. I’ll leave the last word, then, for Jurassic Park‘s cynical mathematician Ian Malcolm:

Dinosaurs and man, two species separated by 65 million years of evolution, have just been suddenly thrown back into the mix together. How can we have the faintest idea of what to expect?

In the VFX ABC, “D” stands for “Dinosaur”. I’ve shared some memorable ones here, but I’m sure you have your favourites too. Tell me about them in the comments box below.

Oh, and while you’re at it, tell me what you’d like to see in Jurassic World. A little Pterodactyl tells me some of the people working on the movie may well be reading this blog, so who knows – maybe your vision of the past could help shape their designs for the future of prehistory.

13 thoughts on “D is for Dinosaur

  1. I think “Jurassic World” is going to have a hard time topping the original “Jurassic Park”. In the years after the original, we’ve been treated to a vast variety of creatures, real, extinct, and imagined, that have filled the silver screen and the small screen at home as well. The pioneering “Walking with Dinosaurs” documentary series did all that could be done about dinosaurs without the human drama, and for those who still wanted the latter, there was “Primeval” on British TV (which was kind of good, until it was cancelled and a Canadian spin-off briefly aired).
    I hope that if “Jurassic World” has kids in the story, that at least they won’t be whining, defenseless characters, like the ones that we’ve seen so far. Obviously, there will be kids, as they are a big part of the intended audience of the “Jurassic” movies… I have to say that at work my friends and I are more excited about the new “Godzilla” movie than about the fourth “Jurassic Park” movie. The first “Jurassic World” teaser trailer better knock our socks off, or else… Anyone agree?

    • You’re right, Eric. “Jurassic Park” reinvented the movie dinosaur big-time. Can it be done again? Would they be foolish even to try? Kids are certainly a possibility, and would be respectful to Crichton’s memory (he said his own children were a big inspiration for the original novel). How about a kid’s movie – literally? “Jurassic World” as an “E.T.” for the 21st century, anyone?

  2. Dinosaurs vs the military. One of my favourite recent action sequences was from ‘The Incredible Hulk’ when Banner hulked-out on a university campus and proceeded to show General Ross’s troops who was The Boss. How about a similar sequence in the new Jurassic sequel? If I remember correctly, the original Jurassic Park novel ended with the island being the target of a military bombardment – a possible general direction perhaps? Think of it – Raptors vs Delta Force :)

    • Sounds spectacular, Gus! It wouldn’t be my choice. I’d rather see something on a smaller scale, character-driven, with some kind of intriguing dinosaur evolution or behaviour. Sure, let’s pull back for some grand shots, but not too many explosions please!

  3. I’m hoping that the Winston team (sans Winston RIP) will be back for animatronics. The key component to Jurassic Park’s longevity is how it uses the technology. Like a close magic magician, the techniques are frequently changing and mixing and matching (which is also the success of LOTR versus the CG sledgehammer of The Hobbit.). In JP, there is a scant 72 or so CG shots, intermixed with hand puppets, animatronics, man-in-suit gags, etc.

    Its when the disciplines come together that the results shine.

    • At the moment, Todd, I’m only aware of ILM and Tippett Studio’s involvement, but I can’t claim to have the inside track. The original “Jurassic Park” is indeed a perfect example of all the different disciplines working in harmony.

  4. About Willis O’Brien and the slurpasaurs, everything you want to know and much (much) more, in Don Shay’s definitive article (Cinefex 7).

    • Yes indeed, Don’s article is so comprehensive it fills Cinefex 7 from cover to cover, and is the best (only?) biography of O’Brien you’ll find. On the subject of the 1960 remake of “The Lost World”, Don writes:

      “OBie was very pleased at the prospect of remaking ‘The Lost World’, but he soon found that he had been engaged more for the publicity value of his name than anything else … Lifelike or not, Obie protested, iguanas and alligators with artificial fins do not look like dinosaurs.”

      It’s clear the stop motion master found the whole experience frustrating and disappointing, but we’re not sure how much of the actual shooting he did – if any. So the question, “Did Obie ever wrangle a baby alligator?” remains unanswered.

  5. In “Willis O’Brien – Special Effects Genius”, Steve Archer quotes Jim Danforth: ”…what ended happening was that O’Brien got relegated to doing nothing on the picture, except to make a lot of storyboard sketches – they didn’t let him do any animation”.

  6. Oh yeah! I love dinosaurs! Dinosaurs are my most favorite type of animal or creature ever!

    But if there one favorite dinosaur that I like, it will be pop culture’s greatest and most famous dinosaur species: The Tyrannosaurus Rex–or T. Rex for short–the Tyrant Lizard King.

    If the lion is the so-called ‘King of Beasts’, The T. Rex, without a doubt is the so-called King of Dinosaurs, though that title may well be debatable for other large theropod dinosaurs such as Giganotosaurus and Spinosaurus will give Tyrannosaurus a run for his money.

    But for me, with its awesome power and brutal nature, The Tyrannosaurus Rex for me represents the dinosaur world’s version of the classic American protagonist: heroic, larger than life, dependent on little, beholden to none.

    Anyway, I always wanted to incorporate dinosaurs into my planned humans, toons n’ dinosaurs epic blockbuster project–possibly Dexter’s Odyssey, which is presumably something of a multi-part big screen live action/animated cartoon hybrid and dinosaur-infused (and samurai-infused) epic fantasy action adventure blockbuster reboot of characters from presumably the mid-to-late 1990s kids cartoon show Dexter’s Laboratory.

    As for Dexter’s Odyssey, it concerns the epic journey (and epic life-altering, history-shaping transformation) of an small and unlikely heroic group of but four youthful (and largely hand-drawn) animated Dexter’s Laboratory toon characters in the person of Dexter, a red-headed boy in a lab coat; Dee Dee, Dexter’s sister in a ballerina’s tutu; and Mee Mee and Lee Lee; Dee Dee’s African American and Asian friends; on an epic LOTR-style quest through an alternate world where dinosaurs roam still and animated cartoon characters interact with real flesh and blood humans as well as the aforementioned dinosaurs–to ensure that one of Dee Dee’s friends Lee Lee fulfill her destiny and stop the evil Mandark (Dexter’s rival neighbor gone evil and powerful like LOTR’s Sauron) from conquering and enslaving their world–and the epic journey of Dexter, Dee Dee, Mee Mee and Lee Lee will be beyond anything anyone in Dexter and Dee Dee’s suburban neighborhood can ever imagine.

    Anyway, I love dinosaurs for they are my favorite type of animal or creature.

    Just saying!

  7. They should show us what happened to the T. Rex form JP1.

    This girl was AWESOME! In my opinion, she held 90% of the success of JP1. We should know what happened to her, may be she can be the main protagonist in the new movie.

    Notice that she didn’t die during the Nublar bombing, not in the movie version, also she didn’t die due to the lack of Lysine… we already knew that all animals survived that, so it’s very likely to be alive and healthful.

  8. Jim Danforth’s Oscar nominated effects from When Dinosaurs Ruled the Earth were done in stop motion, they had built a few mechanical puppets but they did not end up in the film. Roger Dicken made some of the stop motion dinos for that film. Oddly, there is only one dinosaur in the film, the Chasmosaurus, the rest are either made up, or prehistoric animals, but not dinosaurs.
    It should probably be mentioned that Windsor McCay’s 3’rd film featured a drawn animated dinosaur named Gertie in 1914, and in 1928 Herbert M. Dawley and Willis H. O’Brien teamed up to give the world the first live action with stop motion dinosaurs film in the Ghost of Slumber Mountain creating that particular genre.

Comments are closed.